Story Circle: all 8 beats
Best for: Character-driven stories, episodes and short fiction where the inner change is the point.
TV writer Dan Harmon developed the Story Circle as a compact version of Joseph Campbell's hero's journey. He explained it in online essays for other writers and has used it in his own work, including Community and Rick and Morty.
Comfort
-
You
At the very start
Where does your character feel at home?
Read 'home' loosely. A miserable routine counts as long as it is familiar. Name something they do here without thinking, the way a cashier counts change with her eyes on the door. You will stage that same habit again at step eight.
Example: Ruth Amsel tunes pianos for strangers, is gone before anyone offers coffee and has not played for herself in nineteen years. It is a small, safe life.
-
Need
About 13% of the way in
What does your character lack that they can't yet see?
Give the character a want they can state and a need they cannot. The want gets them moving, and the need is what the story delivers in the end. Write each as one line, and keep the need out of the character's mouth until step six.
Example: Ruth takes a job crating the pianos of her home town, Merrow, before a dam floods it, wanting to clear her missing brother Toby's name with the help of her old teacher Maud Hallam, the one person there she trusts. What she needs is to stop running from losing him.
The Unfamiliar
-
Go
About 25% of the way in
What line does your character cross?
Put the far side under rules the old habits can't meet. The crossing has to be a real choice, however small it looks. When they are dragged across with no decision of their own, back up to the moment they could have said no.
Example: Toby's pencil mark inside an upright carries a date three weeks after he supposedly fled, so Ruth moves into his old room and starts opening every piano in town.
-
Search
About 38% of the way in
What does your character give up to get by?
Step four is trial and adjustment. The character tries their old habits, fails, and finds out what this place rewards. Pick the habit from step one that they drop here and the person who makes them drop it. Two or three scenes usually cover it.
Example: Ruth, who avoids people, has to sit in kitchens and listen to old neighbors to reach their pianos. She finds hidden ledger pages, an unwelcome friend in Cal Imrie, the dam's engineer, and old Wick Dunmore, who sweeps the factory's empty seasoning shed and won't say why.
-
Find
About 50% of the way in
How does what your character gets differ from what they expected?
At the bottom of the circle the character gets what they wanted, and it rarely looks as they imagined. This is the furthest point from where they began. Quote the want from step two and show it met in plain terms. Step six needs something to take.
Example: The pages come together and Ruth has what she came for: proof that Toby stole nothing and that the valley's deeds were forged. She also has the fact that follows from it, that he never left Merrow alive.
-
Take
About 63% of the way in
What does it cost your character to keep what they found?
Getting what you want costs something, and this step is the bill. The character may start to see the need behind the want. Pick the thing they would have refused to trade back at step two, and take it. A price they would have agreed to in advance is too cheap.
Example: The last page sits in Maud's piano, and the teacher who has been kind to Ruth all month forged the deeds. Ruth loses the only person in Merrow she trusted, and Maud's son, Deputy Rafe Hallam, has her thrown off the job.
Back, Changed
-
Return
About 75% of the way in
How does your character get back over the line?
The character reaches the line between the two worlds and heads for home with what they gained. Getting back is a crossing in its own right and needs a threat or a deadline. If they have nothing left to lose on the way, the story ended at Take.
Example: Ruth could drive away with her evidence and be safe. Then Wick, who sheltered Toby at the end, tells her he is buried under the seasoning shed, and she turns back toward the rising water to bring her brother home.
-
Change
About 88% of the way in
How is your character different now that they are back where they started?
Bring them back to the first scene's setting or something close to it, where they now hold power over the situation that once held them. Stage the same small event as step one and let them respond in a way a bystander could report.
Example: Ruth tunes a piano for a stranger in a rented room above the new lake. When the owner offers coffee she says yes, sits down at the keyboard and plays.
A circle with eight stops and one idea underneath
Dan Harmon drew the Story Circle as a circle numbered like a clock face, with a horizontal line through it. Above the line is the world the character knows. Below it is the world they don't. A story, in this model, is a trip down through that line and back up. Steps 1 and 2 happen in the known world. Step 3 crosses down. Steps 4, 5 and 6 happen in the unknown. Step 7 crosses back and step 8 lands.
The appeal is how little you have to remember. Harmon cut the hero's journey to eight words, You, Need, Go, Search, Find, Take, Return, Change, and each word is a story instruction. You can sketch a plot on a napkin with them, and writers' rooms use them to break episodes fast.
Find and Take are where the story earns its ending
Many structures treat getting what you want as the end of the plot. The Story Circle puts it at the bottom of the circle, halfway round, and follows it with a price. Step 5 is the character getting the thing. Step 6 is what that costs.
This pairing is why the circle works so well for character stories. A want is on the surface and the need is underneath. Find delivers the want, and Take shows why the want was never enough. In The Water Line, the story behind these examples, the piano tuner Ruth Amsel is crating up her home town before it floods. She proves her brother innocent in step 5, and in step 6 she learns who betrayed him. She has her proof and has lost the last person she trusted.
When you fill in those two steps, write the price first. If the character can pay it without flinching, make it bigger.
Use it at every scale
Circles can sit inside circles, and this is the feature novelists tend to miss. A whole book can be one trip around. So can a part of the book, a chapter or even a single scene. Someone walks into a room wanting something, gets it or doesn't, pays for it and leaves changed. If a chapter feels flat, run it through the eight words and see which one is missing. It is often Take.
This also makes the circle a good match for serial fiction. Each episode can complete a small circle while the season moves along a larger one. Sitcoms depend on this. The character returns to comfort at the end of each half hour with a small change, and the audience enjoys the return as much as the trip.
How it compares with the hero's journey
The two share a shape. The hero's journey has twelve named stages with roles such as mentor and threshold guardian, which suits big external adventures. The Story Circle strips the roles away and keeps the motion. It says nothing about who helps your hero or what the danger looks like, so it fits a quiet novel set in one kitchen as well as it fits a space opera.
Equal spacing is a convenience of the diagram. In a novel the Search often runs longest, and Return can be a few chapters. Use the positions on this sheet as a rough guide and let your material set the real lengths. Filling in the circle usually takes one sitting. Start with You and Change, since they are the same place seen twice.
Draft your Story Circle outline in QuillSpace
The circle closes only when Change answers You. Export the eight steps as Markdown and bring them into QuillSpace, our Mac and Windows writing app. Reread the first and last beats whenever the middle starts to drift.
- Mac: in QuillSpace, choose File > Import and pick your exported .md file.
- Windows: right-click your exported .md file, choose Open with, then QuillSpace.
Free to start. Windows and Mac are separate apps, purchased separately.